Genre: Superhero | Writer: James Robinson | Artist: Nicola Scott, Trevor Scott | Release Date: 2012
Publisher DC Comics
As Earth 2 reels from mounting chaos, new heroes like Green Lantern, Hawkgirl, The Atom and Flash unite to confront the monstrous Grundy, while dark forces threaten to consume the world in decay and destruction.
Written by James Robinson, Earth 2, Issue 5 continues the series’ bold reimagining of a world where the original Trinity—Superman, Batman, and Wonder Woman—are long gone, leaving behind a chaotic battlefield for new heroes to rise. Robinson’s storytelling effectively balances superhero spectacle with the human emotion beneath the masks. The narrative shifts focus between different characters, such as Alan Scott (Green Lantern), Jay Garrick (Flash), and Al Pratt (Atom), who are struggling to come into their own amid escalating threats like Grundy and the forces of The Grey.
The dialogue remains snappy and often insightful, helping differentiate characters with unique voices. The pacing is quick without sacrificing plot cohesion, although new readers may feel a little lost if they’re not caught up. One of Robinson’s strengths lies in world-building—Earth 2 feels distinct and dangerous, with real consequences to its battles. His decision to explore loss, fear, and growth in a post-Trinity world brings unexpected weight to the characters’ journeys.
Rating: 3 out of 5
Nicola Scott and Trevor Scott combine for a visually striking issue. Nicola’s pencils give the characters strong silhouettes and expressive faces, while Trevor’s inks deepen the intensity of both quiet scenes and explosive battles. The panel layouts are fluid and dynamic, making action scenes like the confrontation with Solomon Grundy feel larger than life.
The color palette is dramatic—Earth 2 isn’t a bright, sunny alternate world, but rather one plagued by death and decay, which is represented visually through dark, earthy tones punctuated by bursts of power and supernatural light. Costumes are modernized yet recognizable, with Alan Scott’s Green Lantern suit being a particular standout in both design and color. The monster designs are horrific in the best ways, adding a sense of dread to the already intense storyline. Overall, the art direction feels deliberate, cinematic, and emotionally charged.
Rating: 3 out of 5
In the end, Earth 2, Issue 5 delivers on high stakes and emotional character development, framed by intense visuals and a sleek art style. James Robinson’s writing sets the tone for a world teetering on the brink, while Nicola and Trevor Scott breathe life into every frame. The cover art is especially eye-catching, showcasing the issue’s moody, high-stakes tone and heroic conflict in vivid detail. Earth 2, Issue 5 gets 3 out of 5.
Comments
Post a Comment