Writing
John Wagner delivers a brutal and fast-paced crossover in Predator vs. Judge Dredd, immediately immersing readers in a blood-soaked clash between two of the most iconic enforcers of justice and chaos. Set against the anarchic backdrop of Mega-City One, the story wastes no time introducing the Predator and establishing Dredd’s no-nonsense brand of law. It’s Predator 2 reimagined through the grim lens of Dredd’s dystopia—efficient, relentless, and unapologetically violent. The tension between man and hunter is palpable, and while Dredd is convincingly outmatched at times, his iron will and resourcefulness shine through.
However, the finale fizzles where it should explode. The final confrontation ends too abruptly, robbing readers of a more suspenseful, tactical showdown reminiscent of Dutch’s iconic battle in the original Predator film. A few more pages could’ve elevated this from a solid fight to something unforgettable. The inclusion of Schaefer’s descendant feels like an unnecessary narrative detour. Her exposition-heavy role contributes little to the overall arc, and if Wagner wanted a psychic presence, Judge Anderson would’ve made a far more logical and compelling choice.
Structurally, the story is compact—maybe too compact. There’s potential for a longer, more layered tale with deeper stakes, but what we get is entertaining and loyal to both franchises, even if it plays things a little too safe. Longtime Predator fans may find it predictable, borrowing heavily from familiar beats in Concrete Jungle and Batman vs. Predator. Still, it delivers on its promise of mayhem.
Rating: 3 out of 5
Art Style
Enrique Alcatena’s artwork is gritty, kinetic, and filled with old-school intensity. His thick inks and detailed linework give Mega-City One a dense, lived-in texture, capturing the chaos of the city with confidence. The visual tone matches Wagner’s script beat for beat—claustrophobic alleyways, towering structures, and crime-ridden streets all pulse with energy and decay. The Predator’s design is appropriately menacing, muscular and armored, though not particularly unique. Blood, gore, and carnage are plentiful, marking a welcome departure from the tamer aesthetics seen in the Batman crossover.
The coloring, while serviceable, lacks punch—it’s clear and readable but doesn’t elevate the tension or mood beyond the line art. Panel layouts are well-executed, especially during the action sequences, with solid pacing and a sense of momentum that never loses the reader. Every punch, blast, and impalement lands with weight and consequence. That said, there's nothing visually groundbreaking here—just a consistent, gritty look that does its job without reaching for more.
Alcatena clearly understands the visual language of both franchises, but some of the most imaginative or horrific imagery often associated with Predator mythology is underutilized. A bit more visual ambition could’ve pushed this further, but as it stands, the artwork delivers a satisfying dose of hard-edged violence and dystopian grime.
Rating: 3 out of 5
The Verdict:
In the end, Predator vs. Judge Dredd is an entertaining but predictable crossover that delivers brutal action and solid visuals but never pushes beyond the expected. While the fast pacing and violent spectacle capture the essence of both franchises, the story plays it too safe, missing opportunities for deeper tension and a more intense final showdown. The artwork effectively brings Mega-City One to life, but the writing lacks ambition. A decent read, but nothing groundbreaking. Predator vs. Judge Dredd gets 3 out of 5.
Comments
Post a Comment