Genre: Superhero | Author: Alex Irvine | Publisher: Pocket Books | Release Date: 2007
The Ultimates, a government-backed superhero team, secretly battle the shape-shifting alien Chitauri, who seek humanity’s extinction. As global tensions rise, the team must confront deadly truths and impossible odds to stop an invasion Earth’s conventional forces can't even detect.
Plot
The Ultimates: Against All Enemies follows a darker, grittier version of Marvel’s most iconic superhero team, where espionage and mistrust outweigh traditional heroics. Nick Fury leads the Ultimates in a covert war to locate and destroy the remaining Chitauri—a race of shape-shifting aliens hidden among humans. While the plot’s premise is promising and rooted in paranoia, the actual execution takes time to find its footing. The story unfolds slowly, bogged down in intrigue and inter-team drama that sometimes undercuts the urgency of the alien threat.
Technology plays a strong role in the heroes’ strategy. Tony Stark develops a device that detects Chitauri DNA, while Hank Pym trains ants to sniff them out. These inventive ideas show that the narrative does attempt to think tactically, though the pace remains sluggish for a large stretch. What does work is the subplot involving internal dysfunction: the Ultimates don’t trust each other, and their clashing egos and ideologies often sabotage their own efforts. That interpersonal chaos arguably causes as much damage as the Chitauri threat itself.
The climax picks up steam and offers a worthwhile payoff, though the Chitauri themselves are underwhelming as antagonists. They have no discernible leaders or standout figures, and their motivation—human extinction—is never meaningfully explored. They function as a looming threat rather than as characters. This lack of depth makes the stakes feel a bit hollow, even if the finale delivers some solid tension and payoff. Overall, it’s a solid spy-fi superhero tale, but its slow pacing and flat villains keep it from reaching its full potential.
Rating: 3 out of 5
Production
Alex Irvine’s writing is the standout feature of Against All Enemies. He crafts intense, believable dialogue and isn’t afraid to show the emotional and ideological fractures within the Ultimates. Unlike the camaraderie seen in the MCU’s Avengers, this team is raw, combative, and burdened by personal failures and clashing philosophies. The characterization is grounded and realistic—often brutally so.
Captain America struggles with disillusionment as he confronts the moral gray areas of modern warfare and government secrecy. His belief in transparency conflicts with the shadowy nature of the Ultimates’ work. Nick Fury emerges as one of the more sympathetic characters, juggling pressure from superiors, an unraveling team, and a mission that never ends. Hank Pym, depicted as deeply flawed and often unlikeable, still manages to evoke occasional sympathy—a testament to Irvine’s nuanced writing. Janet Pym’s separation from Hank adds emotional weight, though she doesn’t get nearly enough narrative space. Tony Stark remains sharp and ego-driven, while Clint Barton comes across as a quiet badass. Thor’s contributions are minimal, and his subplot with Loki feels like a distraction.
The writing also incorporates glimpses into the Chitauri perspective, offering insight into their thought process and tactics. While these segments can feel slow or skippable, they do add a layer of alien psychology that’s rare in superhero fiction. Unfortunately, without a memorable antagonist among them, these insights don’t build toward a meaningful villain arc.
Action scenes exist but aren’t the focal point. Those expecting wall-to-wall superhero battles may be disappointed. This is a cerebral take on the genre, prioritizing tension, secrecy, and mistrust over spectacle.
Rating: 4 out of 5
The Verdict
In the end, The Ultimates: Against All Enemies offers a grounded, cerebral look at superhero warfare, loaded with tension, espionage, and dysfunction. While the Chitauri lack presence and the story takes time to pick up speed, the complex character dynamics and sharp writing keep things engaging. It’s not the action-packed adventure some might expect, but for fans of character-driven superhero fiction, it’s worth a read. Alex Irvine delivers a mature, political spin on Marvel’s edgiest team. The Ultimates: Against All Enemies earns 3 out of 5.
Comments
Post a Comment